Used EPD | Positions | Time | Hash | Threads | Database |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
epd\simex.epd | 8238 | depth=1 | 64Mb | 1 | data\sf_family.data |
No. | Engine | Do098 | Do1.2 | Fire7 | Houd5 | Houd6 | Kom10 | Kom11 | Kom12 | Komo1 | Komo9 | Nirv2 | SF10 | SF5 | SF6 | SF7 | SF8 | SF9 | Shr12 | Shr13 | Stre2 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Do098 | xxxxx | 95.72 | 39.57 | 44.55 | 40.71 | 46.56 | 43.68 | 42.99 | 91.07 | 53.88 | 48.10 | 39.94 | 51.08 | 49.06 | 44.91 | 44.55 | 42.10 | 48.54 | 47.24 | 61.28 |
2 | Do1.2 | 95.72 | xxxxx | 39.04 | 44.41 | 40.54 | 46.31 | 43.55 | 42.82 | 92.66 | 53.73 | 47.76 | 39.37 | 50.89 | 48.91 | 44.64 | 44.25 | 41.81 | 48.06 | 46.74 | 61.51 |
3 | Fire7 | 39.57 | 39.04 | xxxxx | 53.04 | 53.95 | 52.46 | 51.13 | 50.03 | 39.53 | 45.17 | 51.90 | 56.00 | 57.13 | 64.40 | 78.41 | 69.05 | 61.52 | 40.21 | 56.16 | 37.78 |
4 | Houd5 | 44.55 | 44.41 | 53.04 | xxxxx | 73.25 | 67.92 | 65.70 | 64.53 | 44.93 | 63.33 | 51.13 | 54.61 | 52.69 | 57.72 | 61.65 | 61.40 | 57.82 | 43.55 | 55.20 | 41.33 |
5 | Houd6 | 40.71 | 40.54 | 53.95 | 73.25 | xxxxx | 67.97 | 70.20 | 69.90 | 41.14 | 55.81 | 50.15 | 56.94 | 51.84 | 57.25 | 60.88 | 62.77 | 60.18 | 40.63 | 54.27 | 38.81 |
6 | Kom10 | 46.56 | 46.31 | 52.46 | 67.92 | 67.97 | xxxxx | 80.91 | 79.24 | 46.46 | 63.53 | 51.67 | 54.61 | 53.89 | 57.74 | 60.78 | 60.43 | 58.28 | 43.80 | 58.13 | 41.80 |
7 | Kom11 | 43.68 | 43.55 | 51.13 | 65.70 | 70.20 | 80.91 | xxxxx | 92.92 | 43.41 | 59.63 | 51.11 | 54.92 | 53.16 | 57.05 | 59.57 | 60.32 | 58.93 | 43.35 | 57.20 | 40.62 |
8 | Kom12 | 42.99 | 42.82 | 50.03 | 64.53 | 69.90 | 79.24 | 92.92 | xxxxx | 42.72 | 59.02 | 49.68 | 54.17 | 52.24 | 55.73 | 58.00 | 58.56 | 57.66 | 42.78 | 56.28 | 40.24 |
9 | Komo1 | 91.07 | 92.66 | 39.53 | 44.93 | 41.14 | 46.46 | 43.41 | 42.72 | xxxxx | 53.94 | 48.37 | 39.87 | 50.85 | 48.92 | 44.77 | 44.31 | 41.85 | 48.05 | 46.86 | 60.74 |
10 | Komo9 | 53.88 | 53.73 | 45.17 | 63.33 | 55.81 | 63.53 | 59.63 | 59.02 | 53.94 | xxxxx | 49.64 | 46.38 | 53.05 | 53.91 | 51.81 | 51.36 | 48.94 | 46.44 | 52.14 | 47.47 |
11 | Nirv24 | 48.10 | 47.76 | 51.90 | 51.13 | 50.15 | 51.67 | 51.11 | 49.68 | 48.37 | 49.64 | xxxxx | 50.65 | 65.24 | 63.77 | 59.05 | 57.20 | 54.19 | 48.04 | 56.22 | 47.58 |
12 | SF10 | 39.94 | 39.37 | 56.00 | 54.61 | 56.94 | 54.61 | 54.92 | 54.17 | 39.87 | 46.38 | 50.65 | xxxxx | 53.12 | 57.86 | 64.10 | 66.71 | 75.41 | 41.25 | 54.78 | 38.25 |
13 | SF5 | 51.08 | 50.89 | 57.13 | 52.69 | 51.84 | 53.89 | 53.16 | 52.24 | 50.85 | 53.05 | 65.24 | 53.12 | xxxxx | 77.90 | 67.06 | 63.88 | 57.66 | 49.05 | 59.55 | 49.48 |
14 | SF6 | 49.06 | 48.91 | 64.40 | 57.72 | 57.25 | 57.74 | 57.05 | 55.73 | 48.92 | 53.91 | 63.77 | 57.86 | 77.90 | xxxxx | 77.67 | 71.96 | 63.88 | 48.84 | 63.93 | 48.05 |
15 | SF7 | 44.91 | 44.64 | 78.41 | 61.65 | 60.88 | 60.78 | 59.57 | 58.00 | 44.77 | 51.81 | 59.05 | 64.10 | 67.06 | 77.67 | xxxxx | 84.14 | 71.70 | 45.49 | 65.12 | 43.62 |
16 | SF8 | 44.55 | 44.25 | 69.05 | 61.40 | 62.77 | 60.43 | 60.32 | 58.56 | 44.31 | 51.36 | 57.20 | 66.71 | 63.88 | 71.96 | 84.14 | xxxxx | 75.51 | 45.71 | 63.19 | 42.73 |
17 | SF9 | 42.10 | 41.81 | 61.52 | 57.82 | 60.18 | 58.28 | 58.93 | 57.66 | 41.85 | 48.94 | 54.19 | 75.41 | 57.66 | 63.88 | 71.70 | 75.51 | xxxxx | 43.55 | 58.83 | 39.76 |
18 | Shr12 | 48.54 | 48.06 | 40.21 | 43.55 | 40.63 | 43.80 | 43.35 | 42.78 | 48.05 | 46.44 | 48.04 | 41.25 | 49.05 | 48.84 | 45.49 | 45.71 | 43.55 | xxxxx | 48.46 | 47.31 |
19 | Shr13 | 47.24 | 46.74 | 56.16 | 55.20 | 54.27 | 58.13 | 57.20 | 56.28 | 46.86 | 52.14 | 56.22 | 54.78 | 59.55 | 63.93 | 65.12 | 63.19 | 58.83 | 48.46 | xxxxx | 44.19 |
20 | Stre2 | 61.28 | 61.51 | 37.78 | 41.33 | 38.81 | 41.80 | 40.62 | 40.24 | 60.74 | 47.47 | 47.58 | 38.25 | 49.48 | 48.05 | 43.62 | 42.73 | 39.76 | 47.31 | 44.19 | xxxxx |
Similarity testing on the evaluation function. Used level is depth=1 thus excluding (the main) search. |
Notes |
1. A similarity of 60-64% is colored yellow. |
2. A similarity of 65 or higher is colored red. |
Do098 = Doch 0.98 (early Komodo) CCRL : 2855 Similarity with : Strelka 2.0 |
Do1.2 = Doch 1.2 (early Komodo) CCRL : 2866 Similarity with : Strelka 2.0 |
Komo1 = Komodo 1 CCRL : 2932 Similarity with : Strelka 2.0 |
Komo9 = Komodo 9 CCRL : 3343 Similarity with : Houdini 5 |
Kom10 = Komodo 10 CCRL : 3399 Similarity with : Houdini 5&6, Stockfish 7&8 |
Kom11 = Komodo 11 CCRL : 3421 Similarity with : Houdini 5&6, Stockfish 8 |
Kom12 = Komodo 12 CCRL : 3414 Similarity with : Houdini 5, Houdini 6 |
Fire = Fire 7.1 CCRL : 3337 Similarity with : Stockfish 6, Stockfish 7 and 8, Stockfish 9 |
Houd5 = Houdini 5 CCRL : 3421 Similarity with : Komodo 9,10, Komodo 11,12 and Stockfish 7,8 |
Houd6 = Houdini 6 CCRL : 3444 Similarity with : Komodo 10,11,12 and Stockfish 7,8 and 9 |
Nirv = NirvanaChess CCRL : 3129 Similarity with : Stockfish 5 and Stockfish 6 |
Shr12 = Shredder 12 CCRL : 2955 No similarity in sight. |
Shr13 = Shredder 13 CCRL : 3270 Massive elo jump of 325 points, similarity with : Stockfish 6, Stockfish 7 and Stockfish 8 |
3. Engine Do1.2 and Komo1 show a similarity of 92.66% | 4. Engine Do098 and Komo1 show a similarity of 91.07% | 8. Engine Fire7 and SF7 show a similarity of 78.41% | 16. Engine Houd6 and Kom11 show a similarity of 70.20% | 17. Engine Houd6 and Kom12 show a similarity of 69.90% | 18. Engine Fire7 and SF8 show a similarity of 69.05% | 19. Engine Houd6 and Kom10 show a similarity of 67.97% | 20. Engine Houd5 and Kom10 show a similarity of 67.92% | 23. Engine Houd5 and Kom11 show a similarity of 65.70% | 24. Engine Nirv24 and SF5 show a similarity of 65.24% | 25. Engine SF7 and Shr13 show a similarity of 65.12% | 26. Engine Houd5 and Kom12 show a similarity of 64.53% | 27. Engine Fire7 and SF6 show a similarity of 64.40% | 29. Engine SF6 and Shr13 show a similarity of 63.93% | 32. Engine Nirv24 and SF6 show a similarity of 63.77% | 34. Engine Houd5 and Komo9 show a similarity of 63.33% | 35. Engine SF8 and Shr13 show a similarity of 63.19% | 36. Engine Houd6 and SF8 show a similarity of 62.77% | 37. Engine Houd5 and SF7 show a similarity of 61.65% | 38. Engine Fire7 and SF9 show a similarity of 61.52% | 39. Engine Do1.2 and Stre2 show a similarity of 61.51% | 40. Engine Houd5 and SF8 show a similarity of 61.40% | 41. Engine Do098 and Stre2 show a similarity of 61.28% | 42. Engine Houd6 and SF7 show a similarity of 60.88% | 43. Engine Kom10 and SF7 show a similarity of 60.78% | 44. Engine Komo1 and Stre2 show a similarity of 60.74% | 45. Engine Kom10 and SF8 show a similarity of 60.43% | 46. Engine Kom11 and SF8 show a similarity of 60.32% | 47. Engine Houd6 and SF9 show a similarity of 60.18% |